为什么CSP实现只涵盖通道?

huangapple go评论86阅读模式
英文:

Why do CSP implementations only cover channels?

问题

在关于通信顺序进程的书中,花了很多时间来定义事件,这些事件没有方向,可以涉及多个独立的进程。

只有在第4章中引入了通道,这些通道是有方向的,涉及两个进程。

然而,包括occam、Go、LuaCSP和clojure.core.async在内的所有CSP实现都只实现了通道。

尽管大多数实际问题可以通过(广播)通道来解决,但我想知道为什么这本书在事件上花了这么多时间,而没有人使用它们。

英文:

In the book about Communicating Sequential Processes a lot of time is spent defining events, which have no direction and can involve multiple independent processes.

Only in chapter 4 are channels introduced, which are directed and involve 2 processes.

Yet all implementations of CSP including occam, Go, LuaCSP and clojure.core.async only implement channels.

Even though most practical problems can be solved with (broadcast) channels, I wonder why the book spends so much time on them while nobody uses them.

答案1

得分: 9

首先,这本书是在实现之前发生的。因此,你的问题最好这样表述:

> 为什么CSP的实现没有将事件作为重点,尽管这本书非常强调它们。

基本上,将事件作为语言的一等公民会给它带来一定的使用特定性,这可能对于通用编程语言来说太狭窄了。

此外,你可以在通道(和其他结构)上轻松实现事件,如果你对事件驱动编程感兴趣。

英文:

Well first of all the book happened before the implementations. Therefore your question is better formulated as:

> Why does no implementation of CSP put a major focus on events even though the book emphazises them greatly.

Basically, making events a first-class citizen of a language gives it a certain usage specificity that would probably be too narrow for a general purpose programming language.

Additionally, you can easily implement events on channels (and other constructs), in case you are into event driven programming.

答案2

得分: 2

在Occam-pi中,屏障是通道的重要补充。通过屏障,每个已注册的进程都会等待屏障,直到它们都这样做为止。在此时,它们都会被释放。这是CSP事件的一种非通道形式的示例。

Occam-pi还使用通道实现了扩展的会合。这是一种与Ada中的会合非常相似的通道使用模式。

英文:

In Occam-pi, barriers are an important adjunct to channels. With a barrier, each enrolled process waits on the barrier until they have all done so. At this point they are all released. This is an example of a non-channel form of CSP event.

Occam-pi also has an extended rendezvous using channels. This is a quite different pattern of usage of channels, very similar to the rendezvous in Ada.

huangapple
  • 本文由 发表于 2013年7月5日 17:49:04
  • 转载请务必保留本文链接:https://go.coder-hub.com/17485909.html
匿名

发表评论

匿名网友

:?: :razz: :sad: :evil: :!: :smile: :oops: :grin: :eek: :shock: :???: :cool: :lol: :mad: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :idea: :arrow: :neutral: :cry: :mrgreen:

确定