英文:
Checking of variable implements interface without compiling
问题
我想知道一个具体类型是否实现了特定的接口,并将其打印出来。
我已经写了一个示例[0],其中定义了一个自定义的结构体(MyPoint),它不是一个接口类型。MyPoint具有在io.Reader接口中定义的Read函数:
type MyPoint struct {
    X, Y int
}
func (pnt *MyPoint) Read(p []byte) (n int, err error) {
    return 42, nil
}
目标是获取具体类型p是否实现了io.Writer接口的信息。
因此,我写了一个简短的main函数来进行检查,希望能得到一个true的结果。
func main() {
    p := MyPoint{1, 2}
}
最初的想法是使用反射和类型断言来检查,将check(p)添加到main函数中。
func checkType(tst interface{}) {
    switch tst.(type) {
    case nil:
        fmt.Printf("nil")
    case *io.Reader:
        fmt.Printf("p is of type io.Reader\n")
    case MyPoint:
        fmt.Printf("p is of type MyPoint\n")
    default:
        fmt.Println("p is unknown.")
    }
}
输出结果是:p is of type MyPoint。经过一些研究,我知道我应该预料到这个结果,因为Go的类型是静态的,所以p的类型是MyPoint,而不是io.Reader。此外,io.Reader是一个接口类型,与MyPoint类型不同。
我在[1]找到了一个解决方案,它在编译时检查MyPoint是否可以是io.Reader。它是有效的。
var _ io.Reader = (*MyPoint)(nil)
但这不是我想要的解决方案。类似下面的尝试也失败了。我认为这是因为上述原因,对吗?
i := interface{}(new(MyPoint))
if _, ok := i.(io.Reader); ok {
    fmt.Println("i is an io.Reader")
}
pType := reflect.TypeOf(p)
if _, ok := pType.(io.Reader); ok {
    fmt.Println("The type of p is compatible to io.Reader")
}
readerType := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
fmt.Printf("p impl. Reader %t \n", pType.Implements(readerType))
是否存在一种在不编译的情况下检查p是否实现了该接口的解决方案?我希望有人能帮助我。
[0] http://play.golang.org/p/JCsFf7y74C(已修复)
http://play.golang.org/p/cIStOOI84Y(旧版)
英文:
I want to know whether a concrete type implements a specefic interface and print it out.
I have written an example [0] with a self defined struct (MyPoint) beeing not an interface-type. MyPoint has the function Read as defined in the interface of io.Reader:
type MyPoint struct {
    X, Y int
}
func (pnt *MyPoint) Read(p []byte) (n int, err error) {
    return 42, nil
}
The aim is to get the information that the concrete type p implements the interface io.Writer.
Therefore I have written a short main trieng to get a true for the check.
func main() {
    p := MyPoint{1, 2}
}
The first idea was to check it with the help of reflection and a type-switch and adding check(p) to to the main-function.
func checkType(tst interface{}) {
	switch tst.(type) {
	case nil:
		fmt.Printf("nil")
	case *io.Reader:
		fmt.Printf("p is of type io.Reader\n")
	case MyPoint:
		fmt.Printf("p is of type MyPoint\n")
	default:
		fmt.Println("p is unknown.")
	}
}
The output is: p is of type MyPoint. After a bit of research I know that I should have expected that because Go's types are static and therefore the type of p is MyPoint and not io.Reader. In addition to that io.Reader is an interface-type which is different to type MyPoint.
I found one solution e.g. at [1] which checks whether MyPoint can be an io.Reader at compile time. It works.
var _ io.Reader = (*MyPoint)(nil)
But that isn't the solution I wanted. Tries like below fails, too. I think it's because of the reason above, isn't it?
i := interface{}(new(MyPoint))
	if _, ok := i.(io.Reader); ok {
		fmt.Println("i is an io.Reader")
}
pType := reflect.TypeOf(p)
if _, ok := pType.(io.Reader); ok {
	fmt.Println("The type of p is compatible to io.Reader")
}
readerType := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
fmt.Printf("p impl. Reader %t \n", pType.Implements(readerType))
Exists one solution to check whether p implements the interface without compiling? I hope that someone can help me.
[0] http://play.golang.org/p/JCsFf7y74C (fixed)
http://play.golang.org/p/cIStOOI84Y (old)
答案1
得分: 8
你想要的功能完全可以使用reflect包来实现。以下是一个示例:
package main
import (
	"fmt"
	"io"
	"reflect"
)
type Other int
type MyPoint struct {
	X, Y int
}
func (pnt *MyPoint) Read(p []byte) (n int, err error) {
	return 42, nil
}
func check(x interface{}) bool {
	// 声明一个表示io.Reader的类型对象
	reader := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
	// 获取参数所表示对象的指针的类型对象,并判断是否实现了io.Reader接口
	return reflect.PtrTo(reflect.TypeOf(x)).Implements(reader)
}
func main() {
	x := MyPoint{0, 0}
	y := Other(1)
	fmt.Println(check(x)) // true
	fmt.Println(check(y)) // false
}
关键点在于注意指针的处理方式。
英文:
It is perfectly possible to do what you want with the reflect package. Here is an example:
package main
import (
    "fmt"
    "io"
    "reflect"
)
type Other int
type MyPoint struct {
    X, Y int
}
func (pnt *MyPoint) Read(p []byte) (n int, err error) {
    return 42, nil
}
func check(x interface{}) bool {
    // Declare a type object representing io.Reader
    reader := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
    // Get a type object of the pointer on the object represented by the parameter
    // and see if it implements io.Reader
    return reflect.PtrTo(reflect.TypeOf(x)).Implements(reader)
}
func main() {
    x := MyPoint{0, 0}
    y := Other(1)
    fmt.Println(check(x)) // true
    fmt.Println(check(y)) // false
}
The tricky point is to pay attention to how pointers are handled.
答案2
得分: 5
存在一种方法可以在不编译代码的情况下检查 p 是否实现了接口吗?
是的:仔细阅读代码 ![]()
这怎么可能呢?如果 p 的方法集包含了接口 i,那么 p 就实现了接口 i。你总是需要编译代码。
我猜你想在运行时而不是在编译时失败。诀窍是获取一个非空的接口类型,然后可以使用 reflect.Type 的 Implements 方法进行测试:
pt := reflect.TypeOf(&MyPoint{})
ioReaderType := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
fmt.Println(pt.Implements(ioReaderType))  //  ==> true
http://play.golang.org/p/2Qcpfjm4ft
英文:
> Exists one solution to check whether p implements the interface without compiling?
Yes: Careful reading of the code ![]()
How could that be possible? p implements some interface i if the method set of p covers i. You will always have to compile the code.
I assume you want to fail not during compilation but just print during runtime.
The trick is getting a non-nil interface type which can be tested with the Implements method of reflect.Type:
pt := reflect.TypeOf(&MyPoint{})
ioReaderType := reflect.TypeOf((*io.Reader)(nil)).Elem()
fmt.Println(pt.Implements(ioReaderType))  //  ==> true
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。


评论