英文:
Implications for COM Interfaces that don't inherit from IUnknown
问题
我试图实现一些可以在导出 Word 文档为 PDF时使用的 COM 接口。其中一些接口不继承自 IUnknown
,例如:
#undef INTERFACE
#define INTERFACE IMsoServerFileManagerSite
DECLARE_INTERFACE(IMsoServerFileManagerSite)
{
STDMETHOD_(BOOL, FGetHandle) (const WCHAR *pwzFileName, HANDLE *phFile, BOOL fRead, BOOL fWrite) PURE;
STDMETHOD_(BOOL, FCloseHandle) (HANDLE hFile) PURE;
};
我发现如果我使用 local 属性(声明它们不是远程接口),可以将这些接口翻译为 IDL。例如:
[
local,
uuid(f8e47685-e402-4119-aa07-4ea4ff1f1123)
]
interface IMsoServerFileManagerSite
{
BOOL FGetHandle(const WCHAR *pwzFileName, HANDLE *phFile, BOOL fRead, BOOL fWrite);
BOOL FCloseHandle(HANDLE hFile);
}
还有另一个接口 IMsoDocExporter
,它继承自 IUnknown
,但有一些返回 void
而不是 HRESULT
的函数。当我将实现此接口的对象传递给 Word API 时,我可以附加调试器并看到我的 dll 被诸如 combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface
的函数调用。
所以我的问题是:
-
combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface
是否意味着我的对象正在远程查询?(即我将需要代理/存根,并且不能使用[local]
属性?) -
如果接口使用非自动化类型,比如
HANDLE
,并且不返回HRESULT
,它仍然可以进行封送吗? -
是否有一种方法/最佳方法将这些接口翻译为 IDL,以便 MIDL 将提供代理/存根实现?(例如,MIDL 参考建议可以使用 call_as 将这些函数映射到远程调用函数 - 对于
HANDLE
我仍然不清楚可以做什么)
英文:
I am trying to implement some COM interfaces that can be used while exporting Word documents as PDF. Some of these interfaces don't inherit from IUnknown
, for instance:
#undef INTERFACE
#define INTERFACE IMsoServerFileManagerSite
DECLARE_INTERFACE(IMsoServerFileManagerSite)
{
STDMETHOD_(BOOL, FGetHandle) (const WCHAR *pwzFileName, HANDLE *phFile, BOOL fRead, BOOL fWrite) PURE;
STDMETHOD_(BOOL, FCloseHandle) (HANDLE hFile) PURE;
};
I found that I can translate these interfaces to IDL if I use the local attribute (declaring that they aren't remote). For instance
[
local,
uuid(f8e47685-e402-4119-aa07-4ea4ff1f1123)
]
interface IMsoServerFileManagerSite
{
BOOL FGetHandle(const WCHAR *pwzFileName, HANDLE *phFile, BOOL fRead, BOOL fWrite);
BOOL FCloseHandle(HANDLE hFile);
}
Another such interface, IMsoDocExporter
, does inherit from IUnknown
, but has some functions that return void
rather than HRESULT
. When I pass an object implementing this interface to the Word API I can attach a debugger and see that my dll is being called by functions like combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface
.
So my questions are:
-
Does
combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface
mean that my object is being queried remotely? (i.e. I'll need a proxy/stub, and can't use the[local]
attr?) -
if an interface uses non-automation types, such as
HANDLE
, and doesn't return anHRESULT
can it still be marshalled? -
is there a way/what is the best way to translate these interfaces to IDL so that MIDL will provide the proxy/stub implementation? (e.g. MIDL reference suggested that call_as could be used to map these functions to remote callable functions -- still unclear what I could do with
HANDLE
though)
答案1
得分: 1
在进一步尝试后,我终于设法使其正常工作。@molbdnilo和@Jonathan Potter是正确的。只有IMsoDocExporter
接口是COM对象,并且继承自IUnknown
。其他接口似乎只是普通的虚表,它们似乎无法进行封送(至少不能不写大量自定义代理/存根代码)。
>1. combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface是否意味着我的对象正在远程查询?
是的,但这只适用于IMsoDocExporter
(实际的COM对象)
>2. 如果一个接口使用非自动化类型,如HANDLE,并且不返回HRESULT,它仍然可以被封送吗?
事实证明是的。正如我在原始帖子中提到的,您可以将这些方法标记为[local]
,然后定义一个类似的方法,带有[call_as]
属性,返回HRESULT
并具有可进行RPC的参数。然后,您只需要定义将一个调用转换为另一个调用的函数。最终,要封送一个HANDLE
,您需要指定类型信息。
英文:
After some more playing around I finally managed to make it work. @molbdnilo and @Jonathan Potter were correct. Only the IMsoDocExporter
interface is a COM object, and it inherits from IUnknown
. The other interfaces are just plain vtables I suppose and it seems that they can't be marshalled (at least not without writing lots of custom proxy/stub code).
>1. Does combase.dll!CRemoteUnknown::RemQueryInterface mean that my object is being queried remotely?
Yes, but this only applied to IMsoDocExporter
(the actual COM object)
>2. if an interface uses non-automation types, such as HANDLE, and doesn't return an HRESULT can it still be marshalled?
It turns out yes. As mentioned in my original post you can mark these methods [local]
and then define a similar method with the [call_as]
attribute that returns HRESULT
and has RPC-able parameters. Then you just need to define the functions that translates one call to the other. Ultimately, to marshal a HANDLE
you need to specify the type information.
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。
评论