英文:
Counts by date and status with intermittent data
问题
我想要统计特定日期的特定状态下的对象数量(例如:灯泡、计划任务、客户账单状态)。然而,数据是不连续的。对象可能在特定日期有行,也可能没有。
不是一个简单的按“GROUP BY”解决的问题。统计“特定状态下的对象数量”的要求依赖于之前的行。
在下面的最小问题示例中,如果在03-01进行“GROUP BY”操作,结果将是“1个开启和1个关闭”。在03-02只有一个对象。进行03-02的“GROUP BY”操作结果将是“1个开启和0个关闭”。03-02的正确答案应该是“2个开启和1个关闭”,因为它必须包括03-01日期的对象。
要解决的最小问题示例如下:
SET NOCOUNT ON
-->>-- 最小问题示例 -- 按日期统计状态数量
IF OBJECT_ID('tempdb..#d') IS NOT NULL DROP TABLE #d
CREATE TABLE #d (ndx SMALLINT IDENTITY(1,1), id TINYINT, dt DATE, status CHAR(10) )
INSERT INTO #d (id, dt, status)
VALUES
( 1, '20230301' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230301' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230302' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230303' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230305' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230308' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230308' , 'off' )
, ( 1, '20230310' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230311' , 'off' )
, ( 1, '20230312' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230312' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230313' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230314' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230314' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230316' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230320' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230321' , 'off' )
SELECT * FROM #d d ORDER BY id, dt
IF OBJECT_ID('tempdb..#c') IS NOT NULL DROP TABLE #c
CREATE TABLE #c ( calendardt DATE )
INSERT INTO #c(calendardt)
VALUES
('2023-03-01 '), ('2023-03-02 '), ('2023-03-03 '), ('2023-03-04 '), ('2023-03-05 ')
, ('2023-03-06 '), ('2023-03-07 '), ('2023-03-08 '), ('2023-03-09 '), ('2023-03-10 ')
, ('2023-03-11 '), ('2023-03-12 '), ('2023-03-13 '), ('2023-03-14 '), ('2023-03-15 ')
, ('2023-03-16 '), ('2023-03-17 '), ('2023-03-18 '), ('2023-03-19 '), ('2023-03-20 ')
, ('2023-03-21 '), ('2023-03-22 '), ('2023-03-23 '), ('2023-03-24 '), ('2023-03-25 ')
SELECT * FROM #c UNION ALL SELECT * FROM #c ORDER BY calendardt
SELECT *
FROM #c c
LEFT JOIN #d d ON d.dt = c.calendardt
ORDER BY c.calendardt, d.id
期望的结果如下:
-->>-- 期望的结果
calendardt [status] [count]
2023-03-01 on 1
2023-03-01 off 1
2023-03-02 on 2
2023-03-02 off 1
2023-03-03 on 2
2023-03-03 off 1
2023-03-04 on 2
2023-03-04 off 1
2023-03-05 on 3
2023-03-05 off 0
2023-03-06 on 3
2023-03-06 off 0
2023-03-07 on 3
2023-03-07 off 0
2023-03-08 on 1
2023-03-08 off 2
2023-03-09 on 1
2023-03-09 off 2
2023-03-10 on 1
2023-03-10 off 2
2023-03-11 on 1
2023-03-11 off 2
2023-03-12 on 1
2023-03-12 off 2
2023-03-13 on 0
2023-03-13 off 3
2023-03-14 on 0
2023-03-14 off 3
2023-03-15 on 0
2023-03-15 off 3
2023-03-16 on 0
2023-03-16 off 3
我没有尝试,我能够按每天跟踪数据的变化。我可以捕获对象首次进入新状态的日期,并计算它在该状态下停留的时间。但是,我无法计算按日期和状态的总数。任何关于按日期和状态进行计数的帮助将不胜感激。
英文:
I would like to count the number of objects (lightbulbs, scheduled jobs, customer billing status) that are in a specific status by date. However, the data is intermittent. Objects may or may not have a row on a specific date.
Not a simple GROUP BY solution. The requirement for number of objects "in a specific status" depends on previous rows.
In the minimum problem to solve example below, on 03-01 a GROUP BY would result in "1 on and 1 off". On 03-02 only a single object is represented. A GROUP BY showing 03-02 results would be "1 on and 0 off". The correct answer for total objects by status on 03-02 is "2 on and 1 off" because it must include the objects with rows on 03-01.
A minimum problem to solve is here
SET NOCOUNT ON
-->>-- minimum problem to solve -- count by status for a specific day
IF OBJECT_ID('tempdb..#d') IS NOT NULL DROP TABLE #d
CREATE TABLE #d (ndx SMALLINT IDENTITY(1,1), id TINYINT, dt DATE, status CHAR(10) )
INSERT INTO #d (id, dt, status)
VALUES
( 1, '20230301' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230301' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230302' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230303' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230305' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230308' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230308' , 'off' )
, ( 1, '20230310' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230311' , 'off' )
, ( 1, '20230312' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230312' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230313' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230314' , 'on' )
, ( 3, '20230314' , 'off' )
, ( 3, '20230316' , 'off' )
, ( 2, '20230320' , 'on' )
, ( 1, '20230321' , 'off' )
SELECT * FROM #d d ORDER BY id, dt
IF OBJECT_ID('tempdb..#c') IS NOT NULL DROP TABLE #c
CREATE TABLE #c ( calendardt DATE )
INSERT INTO #c(calendardt)
VALUES
('2023-03-01 '), ('2023-03-02 '), ('2023-03-03 '), ('2023-03-04 '), ('2023-03-05 ')
, ('2023-03-06 '), ('2023-03-07 '), ('2023-03-08 '), ('2023-03-09 '), ('2023-03-10 ')
, ('2023-03-11 '), ('2023-03-12 '), ('2023-03-13 '), ('2023-03-14 '), ('2023-03-15 ')
, ('2023-03-16 '), ('2023-03-17 '), ('2023-03-18 '), ('2023-03-19 '), ('2023-03-20 ')
, ('2023-03-21 '), ('2023-03-22 '), ('2023-03-23 '), ('2023-03-24 '), ('2023-03-25 ')
SELECT * FROM #c UNION ALL SELECT * FROM #c ORDER BY calendardt
SELECT *
FROM #c c
LEFT JOIN #d d ON d.dt = c.calendardt
ORDER BY c.calendardt, d.id
The expected result should look like this
-->>-- expected result
calendardt [status] [count]
2023-03-01 on 1
2023-03-01 off 1
2023-03-02 on 2
2023-03-02 off 1
2023-03-03 on 2
2023-03-03 off 1
2023-03-04 on 2
2023-03-04 off 1
2023-03-05 on 3
2023-03-05 off 0
2023-03-06 on 3
2023-03-06 off 0
2023-03-07 on 3
2023-03-07 off 0
2023-03-08 on 1
2023-03-08 off 2
2023-03-09 on 1
2023-03-09 off 2
2023-03-10 on 1
2023-03-10 off 2
2023-03-11 on 1
2023-03-11 off 2
2023-03-12 on 1
2023-03-12 off 2
2023-03-13 on 0
2023-03-13 off 3
2023-03-14 on 0
2023-03-14 off 3
2023-03-15 on 0
2023-03-15 off 3
2023-03-16 on 0
2023-03-16 off 3
I do not have an attempt. I am able to track changes to the data on a per day basis. I can capture the first date the object entered a new status and calculate how long it has been in that status. But I am not able calculate the totals by date and status.
Any help counting by date and status would be appreciated.
答案1
得分: 1
以下是您要翻译的SQL查询的部分:
with changes as (
select id, dt, status
from (select id, dt, status,
case when lag(status) over (partition by id order by dt) = status
then 0 else 1 end chg
from #d) t
where chg = 1),
cal as (
select calendardt dt, id from #c cross join (select distinct id from #d) t),
joined as (
select cal.dt, cal.id,
last_value(status) ignore nulls
over (partition by cal.id order by cal.dt) status
from cal left join changes d on cal.dt = d.dt and d.id = cal.id)
select * --dt, stat_on, stat_off
from joined pivot (count(id) for status in ([on], [off])) piv
order by dt
请注意,代码部分未被翻译,只翻译了SQL查询的内容。
英文:
with changes as (
select id, dt, status
from (select id, dt, status,
case when lag(status) over (partition by id order by dt) = status
then 0 else 1 end chg
from #d) t
where chg = 1),
cal as (
select calendardt dt, id from #c cross join (select distinct id from #d) t),
joined as (
select cal.dt, cal.id,
last_value(status) ignore nulls
over (partition by cal.id order by cal.dt) status
from cal left join changes d on cal.dt = d.dt and d.id = cal.id)
select * --dt, stat_on, stat_off
from joined pivot (count(id) for status in ([on], [off])) piv
order by dt
Initially I made solution in Oracle, dbfiddle is here. My knowledge of SQL Server is very limited and I can test it only in dbfiddle, but it returns expected values (until 13 April, but I think it should be 1 ON, because id=2 is ON).
The idea is to first eliminate rows which do not change anything (status off->off for example), then join with calendar and cross join with all ids. This way we have rows for each day and id. Then last_value fills missing data. And we can aggregate.
答案2
得分: 0
On/off table is missing
..
CREATE TABLE #on_off (status varchar(3));
INSERT INTO #on_off (status)
VALUES
('on'), ('off');
SELECT c.calendardt, c.status, count(d.id) n
FROM (
select c.*, f.*
from #c c
cross join #on_off f
) c
LEFT JOIN #d d ON d.dt = c.calendardt and d.status = c.status
GROUP BY c.calendardt, c.status
ORDER BY c.calendardt, c.status
英文:
On/off table is missing
..
CREATE TABLE #on_off (status varchar(3));
INSERT INTO #on_off (status)
VALUES
('on'), ('off');
SELECT c.calendardt, c.status, count(d.id) n
FROM (
select c.*, f.*
from #c c
cross join #on_off f
) c
LEFT JOIN #d d ON d.dt = c.calendardt and d.status = c.status
GROUP BY c.calendardt, c.status
ORDER BY c.calendardt, c.status
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。
评论