英文:
Are Go modules really usable today given third party "incompatible" modules?
问题
我是新手,正在尝试创建我的第一个Go程序。按照各种入门教程,我创建了一个新模块,但是为了我的目的,这个模块需要依赖于另一个模块:
github.com/timescale/promscale@0.6.2
我的问题是,这个模块有一些依赖没有“正确采用”语义化版本控制的方法。
go list -e -m all
...
k8s.io/client-go v12.0.0+incompatible
...
报告了37个这样的模块...所以联系模块的作者让他们采用SIV,就像我看到的建议那样,可能不是一个选项。
我是不是漏掉了什么,或者我应该完全放弃在这个新项目中使用模块?
英文:
I am new to Go and trying to create my first program. Following the various getting started & tutorials I create a new module, which for my purpose needs to have a dependency on this module:
github.com/timescale/promscale@0.6.2
My problem is that the module has dependencies that have not "properly adopted" the semantic versioning approach.
go list -e -m all
...
k8s.io/client-go v12.0.0+incompatible
...
reports 37 such modules... so contacting the module author to have them adopt SIV, as I have seen suggested, will not be an option.
Am I missing something, or should I simply completely give up on using modules for this new project?
答案1
得分: 2
你好!以下是翻译好的内容:
> 鉴于第三方“不兼容”的模块,Go模块今天真的可用吗?
是的。
> 我有什么遗漏吗?
也许:这个“+incompatible”并不意味着失败。
> 或者我应该完全放弃在这个新项目中使用模块吗?
不,当然不需要完全放弃。
英文:
> Are Go modules really usable today given third party "incompatible" modules?
Yes.
> Am I missing something
Maybe: This "+incompabtible" is not a sign of failure.
> or should I simply completely give up on using modules for this new project?
No, of course not.
答案2
得分: 0
感谢您的答案和评论,看起来:
-
新项目应该使用模块,+不兼容的依赖关系会出现,但这没关系。
-
这个FAQ条目是正确的,只需阅读前两行,将“Additional Details”留到以后。
-
如果存在+不兼容的依赖关系,
go list -m all
不会像所有教程中描述的那样工作,它会在第一个不兼容的模块上出错。
go list -m -e all
似乎按预期工作。
如果您使用Goland,使用GOFLAGS=-e
似乎可以使依赖关系解析正常工作,尽管存在+不兼容的模块。这可能会产生我不知道的副作用。
英文:
Thanks for the answers and comments, it seems that:
-
New project should use modules, +incompatible dependencies will come up but that is fine
-
This FAQ entry has it right, just read the first 2 lines and keep "Additional Details" for a rainy day
-
go list -m all
won't behave as described in all the tutorials if +incompatible dependencies exist, it will choke on the first incompatible module instead.
go list -m -e all
seems to work as expected.
If you are using Goland, using GOFLAGS=-e
seems to make dependency resolution work despite +incompatible modules. This may well have side effects that I am not aware of.
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。
评论