环境变量显然没有传递给systemd服务调用

huangapple go评论86阅读模式
英文:

Environment variables apparently not being passed to a systemd service invocation

问题

以下是翻译好的内容:

这是一个案例:

我正在编写一个 go 程序。

在程序的某个地方,通过 os.Exec() 调用 terragrunt 命令行界面。

该程序在一个安装有 systemd 版本为 232 的机器上运行。

到目前为止,我一直在使用一些暴露的环境变量来调用 terragrunt(正如我们将在下面看到的那样)。

这些环境变量通过 /etc/profile.d/terragruntvars 将它们传递给登录进程,例如:

export TF_VAR_remote_state_bucket=my-bucket-name

因此,当我在终端中运行 terragrunt plan 并通过我的 tf / hcl 文件进行适当的插值时,我会得到类似以下的输出(这是一个 debug 级别的输出,显示了 terragrunt 最终执行的实际 terraform 命令):

terraform init -backend-config=my-bucket-name ...(后面还有更多标志)

我的 go 程序(通过 os.Exec() 调用 terragrunt 命令行界面)通过 go run main.go 完美运行。

我决定将其作为 systemd 服务,如下所示:

[Service]
ExecStart=/bin/sh -c myprogram
EnvironmentFile=/etc/myprogram/config
User=someuser
Group=somegroup

[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target

程序开始严重失败。通过搜索根本原因,我发现在运行时 TF_VAR_* 变量从未传递给服务,因此 terraform 命令变成了这样:

terraform init -backend-config=(这是空的,没有任何内容)

我认为通过显式地通过 bash 调用服务,即将 ExecStart=/bin/sh -c myprogram 这样做,可以解决问题。

接下来是最奇怪的部分。

将这些变量添加到 EnvironmentFile=/etc/myprogram/config 没有任何效果terragrunt 的执行。当我说没有效果时,我的意思是这些变量确实对服务可用,但命令仍然是错误的,即:

terraform init -backend-config=(这是空的,没有任何内容)

然而,TF_VAR_* 变量确实存在。我在程序中添加了一个 os.Exec("env") 并打印它们。

这让我抓狂,所以如果有任何关于可能导致此问题的提示,将不胜感激。

英文:

Here is the case:

I am writing a go program.

At some point, the program calls terragrunt cli, via os.Exec().

The program is run on a machine having systemd version 232.

Up till know, I have been invoking terragrunt with some env vars exposed (required by terragrunt as we will see below)

These env vars are passed to the login process by /etc/profile.d/terragruntvars as in

export TF_VAR_remote_state_bucket=my-bucket-name

So when I run in my terminal say terragrunt plan and by the appropriate interpolation in my tf / hcl files, I get something like (this is a debug level output, showing the actual terraform invocation terragrunt ends up performing)

terraform init -backend-config=my-bucket-name ...(more flags following)

My go program (invoking terragrunt cli via os.Exec()) runs perfectly via go run main.go

I decide to make this a systemd service as in

[Service]
ExecStart=/bin/sh -c myprogram
EnvironmentFile=/etc/myprogram/config
User=someuser
Group=somegroup

[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target

The program started failing miserably. By searching the root case I found out that the TF_VAR_* variables where never passed to the service when running, so the terraform command ended up being like

terraform init -backend-config=(this is empty, nothing here)

I thought that by explicitly invoking the service via bash, i.e. by making ExecStart=/bin/sh -c myprogram this would address the problem.

Here come the weird(est) parts.

Adding these vars to EnvironmentFile=/etc/myprogram/config did not have any effect in the terragrunt execution. When I say no effect, I mean the variables did become available to the service, however the command is still broken, i.e.

terraform init -backend-config=(this is empty, nothing here)

However, the TF_VAR_* variables ARE there. I added an os.Exec("env") in my program and it did print them.

This has been driving me nuts so any hint about what might be causing this would be highly appreciated.

答案1

得分: 2

就像一个外壳不会将其进程的环境变量传递给子进程一样:

$ X=abc
$ bash -c 'echo $X'   # 什么都不打印

除非你导出环境变量:

$ export X
$ bash -c 'echo $X'   # abc

类似地,在使用systemdEnvironmentFile时,要导出环境变量,可以使用PassEnvironment,例如:

PassEnvironment=VAR1 VAR2 VAR3

来自文档

> PassEnvironment=
> 将为系统服务管理器设置的环境变量传递给执行的进程。
> 接受一个以空格分隔的变量名列表...

英文:

Just like a shell will not pass it's process ENV VAR's on to child processes:

$ X=abc
$ bash -c 'echo $X'   # prints nothing

unless you export the environment variable:

$ export X
$ bash -c 'echo $X'   # abc

similarly with systemd and when using EnvironmentFile, to export environment variables, use PassEnvironment e.g.

PassEnvironment=VAR1 VAR2 VAR3

From the docs:

> PassEnvironment=
> Pass environment variables set for the system service manager to executed processes.
> Takes a space-separated list of variable names...

huangapple
  • 本文由 发表于 2021年11月1日 04:43:34
  • 转载请务必保留本文链接:https://go.coder-hub.com/69790451.html
匿名

发表评论

匿名网友

:?: :razz: :sad: :evil: :!: :smile: :oops: :grin: :eek: :shock: :???: :cool: :lol: :mad: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :idea: :arrow: :neutral: :cry: :mrgreen:

确定