Can't figure out why abstract method isn't overriding

My programming assignment tasked me with writing an increase/decreasePay abstract method that must be put in my abstract employee class. I can't seem to get the the method correct in HourlyWorker so that it will take increase or decrease the pay by a "percentage". My math is sound (monthly pay - or + (monthly pay * the percentage), but my output in my test class is coming out the same after increasing/decreasing pay. Any help?

Employee class:

abstract public class Employee
{
private String lastName;
private String firstName;
private String ID;
public abstract void increasePay(double percentage);
public abstract void decreasePay(double percentage);
public abstract double getMonthlyPay();
public Employee(String last, String first, String ID)
{
lastName = last;
firstName = first;
this.ID = ID;
} 
public void setLast(String last)
{
lastName = last;
}
public void setFirst(String first)
{
firstName = first;
}
public void setIdNumber(String ID)
{
this.ID = ID;
}
public String getLastName()
{
return lastName;
}
public String getFirstName()
{
return firstName;
}
public String getName()
{
return firstName + lastName;
}
public String getIdNumber()
{
return ID;
}

}

HourlyWorkerClass

public class HourlyWorker extends Employee
{
private int hours;
private double hourlyRate;
private double monthlyPay;
public HourlyWorker(String last, String first, String ID, double rate)
{
super(last, first, ID);
hourlyRate = rate;
}
public void setHours(int hours)
{
this.hours = hours;
}
public int getHours()
{
return hours;
}
public void setHourlyRate(double rate)
{
if ( hours > 160 )
this.hourlyRate = hourlyRate * 1.5;
else 
this.hourlyRate = rate;
}
public double getHourlyRate()
{
return hourlyRate;
}
public void setMonthlyPay(double monthlyPay)
{
monthlyPay = hourlyRate * hours;
}
public double getMonthlyPay()
{
return hourlyRate * hours;
}
public void increasePay(double percentage)
{
monthlyPay = monthlyPay* percentage;
}
public void decreasePay(double percentage)
{
monthlyPay = monthlyPay* percentage;
}
public String toString() 
{
String result = "Name: " + getFirstName() + " " + getLastName() + "\nID: "
+ getIdNumber() + " \nHourly Rate: " + hourlyRate;
return result;
}
}

Testing class (currently testing increase

public class TestEmployee2
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
Employee [] staff = new Employee[3];
Supervisor sup = new Supervisor("Boss", "Jim", "JB7865", 54000);
HourlyWorker hw1 = new HourlyWorker("Bee", "Busy", "BB1265", 11.95);
hw1.setHours(200);
staff[0] = sup;
staff[1] = hw1;        
System.out.println(staff[0].getMonthlyPay());
staff[0].increasePay(5);
System.out.println(staff[0].getMonthlyPay());
System.out.println(staff[1].getMonthlyPay());
staff[1].increasePay(10);
System.out.println(staff[1].getMonthlyPay());
}
}

Supervisor class:

public class Supervisor extends Employee
{
private double annualSalary;
private double monthlyPay;
public Supervisor(String last, String first, String ID, double salary)
{
super(last, first, ID);
annualSalary = salary;
}
public void setAnnualSalary(double salary)
{
annualSalary = salary;
}
public double getAnnualSalary()
{
return annualSalary;
}
public double getMonthlyPay()
{
return ((annualSalary + (annualSalary * .02)) / 12);
}
public void increasePay(double percentage)
{
monthlyPay = monthlyPay* percentage;
}
public void decreasePay(double percentage)
{
monthlyPay = monthlyPay* percentage;
}
public String toString() 
{
String result = "Name: " + getFirstName() + " " + getLastName() + "\nID: "
+ getIdNumber() + "\nAnnual Salary: " + annualSalary;
return result;
}
}

Output is:

4590.0
4590.0
2390.0
2390.0

Doesn't appear to be modifying getMonthlyPay()

Should be:

4590.00
4819.50
2390.00
2629.00

In increasePay, you are increasing monthlyPay:

public void increasePay(double percentage)
{
monthlyPay = monthlyPay* percentage;
}

But when you getMonthlyPay, you calculate the pay using two other variables - hourlyRate and hours:

public double getMonthlyPay()
{
return hourlyRate * hours;
}

So changing monthlyPay doesn't affect what getMonthlyPay returns. I suspect a similar thing happens in Supervisor.

increasePay should instead increase hourlyRate:

public void increasePay(double percentage)
{
hourlyRate *= 1 + percentage / 100;
}

Also, I don't think you need a monthlyPay field (or setMonthlyPay, for that matter) in HourlyEmployee at all. The monthly rate can always be calculated by hours and hourlyRate.

<hr>

For Supervisor, do the same thing, and change annualSalary rather than monthlyPay:

public double getMonthlyPay()
{
return ((annualSalary + (annualSalary * .02)) / 12);
}
public void increasePay(double percentage)
{
annualSalary *= 1 + percentage / 100;
}