Is there anyway I could retrieve the data of all the films that have the same name but different scores?

When I run the program and choose to search by score, the same title is printed for the same score instead of printing the other titles

  private void searchReviewScore() throws IOException {
    int review = getNumberInput(_scanner, 1, 5, "Enter minimum rating (1 - 5): ");

    // Get the list of scores from the file.
    Path path = Paths.get("scores.txt");
    List<String> allScores = Files.readAllLines(path);

    for (String movieScore : allScores) 
    {
        int movieScoreInt = Integer.parseInt(movieScore);
        if (review <= movieScoreInt) { 
            int i = allScores.indexOf(movieScore);
            presentMovieAndScore(i);
        }
    }
    //TODO: Add call to search movie database based on input

    //TODO: Present results to user

}

Here is my Print method.

/**
 * @param i
 * @throws IOException
 */
private void presentMovieAndScore(int i) throws IOException {
    Path movies = Paths.get("movies.txt");
    List<String> allMovies = Files.readAllLines(movies);

    Path path = Paths.get("scores.txt");
    List<String> allScores = Files.readAllLines(path);

    System.out.println("Titel: " + allMovies.get(i) + " rating: " + allScores.get(i));
}

Here is the content of movie.txt bones
matrix
deceptions
suits
bones
Gladiator

the score.txt contains: 1
2
5
3
4
1

I guess your problem is with this line of code :

> int i = allScores.indexOf(movieScore);

indexOf method returns always first match.
So if your table has same value twice in different positions in table example at 1 and 5 ,it will allways return 1.In this case ,since you want the position of the element using for each loop is not good idea ,try to use index for loop.

private void searchReviewScore() throws IOException {
int review = getNumberInput(_scanner, 1, 5, "Enter minimum rating (1 - 5): ");

// Get the list of scores from the file.
Path path = Paths.get("scores.txt");
List<String> allScores = Files.readAllLines(path);

for ( int i=0; i<allScores.size() ;i++) 
{   
    String movieScore =allScores.get(i);
    int movieScoreInt = Integer.parseInt(movieScore);
    if (review <= movieScoreInt) { 
        presentMovieAndScore(i);
    }
}

}

The problem is that you are chosing the first name for a given score. So when you see 1, you use that to index into your movies and get bones when you really want gladiator. I recommend puting them in a TreeMap<Integer,List<String>> where the key is the score and the value is a list of movies of that score.

Another possibility would be to create a Movie class and store the name and score in the class. That would also be beneficial if you ever want include more information about the movie.

A TreeMap offers some advantages as demostrated below.

The TreeMap lets you chose subMaps base on ranges of the keys. How you populate that map is up to you. You can also choose explicit scores for a list of movies at that rating.

Scanner readMovies = null;
Scanner readScores = null;
try {
readMovies = new Scanner(new File("f:/movies.txt"));
readScores = new Scanner(new File("f:/scores.txt"));
} catch (FileNotFoundException fne) {
	fne.printStackTrace();
}
// read in the values.
// The key is the score.
// the value is a list of movies that have that score.

TreeMap<Integer, List<String>> data = new TreeMap<>();
while (readMovies.hasNext()) {
	data.computeIfAbsent(readScores.nextInt(),
			k -> new ArrayList<>()).add(readMovies.next());
}

//prompt for rating

int minRating = 1;
int maxRating =  3;
// Now as an example, get a list of movies in the range
// of the ratings that exist in the map.
Map<Integer,List<String>> subMap = data.subMap(data.ceilingKey(minRating),
		data.floorKey(maxRating));
// And print them out.
subMap.entrySet().forEach(System.out::println);

In this case this prints.

1=[bones, Gladiator]
2=[matrix]

Since there are no ratings of 3, it stopped at 2.