英文:
How to initialize struct pointer via reflection
问题
我的目标是将一个nil
指针转换为一个结构体(但可以是任何类型),并将其作为interface{}
传递,并在原地初始化一个结构体。
我的测试代码(playground链接)如下:
package main
import (
"fmt"
"reflect"
)
type Foo struct {
Foo string
}
func main() {
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
rv.Set(reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()))
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
}
希望代码本身能够说明问题。但目标基本上是将y
从一个未初始化的指向Foo
的指针((*main.Foo)(nil)
)转换为指向已初始化(零值)的Foo
实例的指针:&main.Foo{Foo:""}
。但是我得到了reflect.Value.Set using unaddressable value
的错误。我不明白为什么我尝试设置的值是不可寻址的。我已经花了一整天的时间阅读标准库JSON解码器的源代码和其他SO帖子,但显然还是忽略了一些东西。
如果我去掉外层的interface{}
:
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y).Elem() // 去掉外层的interface{}
rv.Set(reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()))
错误变成了reflect: call of reflect.Value.Type on zero Value
。
英文:
My goal is to take a nil
pointer to a struct (but could be any type), passed as an interface{}
, and initialize a struct in its place.
My test code (playground link) is:
package main
import (
"fmt"
"reflect"
)
type Foo struct {
Foo string
}
func main() {
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
rv.Set(reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()))
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
}
I hope the code is self-documenting. But the goal is essentially to convert y
which begins as an uninitialized pointer to Foo
, ((*main.Foo)(nil)
) into a pointer to an initialized (zero-value) instance ofFoo
: &main.Foo{Foo:""}
. But I'm getting reflect.Value.Set using unaddressable value
. I don't understand why the value I'm attempting to set is unaddressable. I've spent the day reading through the source code to the standard library JSON unmarshaler, and other SO posts, but am still clearly overlooking something.
If I peel away the outer interface{}
:
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y).Elem() // Remove the outer interface{}
rv.Set(reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()))
the error becomes reflect: call of reflect.Value.Type on zero Value
.
答案1
得分: 4
请尝试这样做:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
// 必须取得 y 的地址来设置它。使用 Elem() 解引用以获取 y 的值
rv := reflect.ValueOf(&y).Elem()
// 接口元素类型是 *main.Foo,使用 Elem() 解引用以获取 main.Foo
t := rv.Elem().Type().Elem()
rv.Set(reflect.New(t))
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
你也可以通过赋值给 y
而不是使用反射来设置它:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
t := rv.Type().Elem()
y = reflect.New(t).Interface()
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
英文:
Try this:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
// Must take address of y to set it. Dereference with Elem() to get value for y
rv := reflect.ValueOf(&y).Elem()
// Interface element type is *main.Foo, dereference with Elem() to get main.Foo
t := rv.Elem().Type().Elem()
rv.Set(reflect.New(t))
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
You can also assign y
instead of setting it via reflection:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
t := rv.Type().Elem()
y = reflect.New(t).Interface()
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
答案2
得分: 1
在你的示例中,rv.CanAddr()
的返回值为false
,因此你无法设置它(rv.CanSet()
的返回值也是false
)。
问题在于,如果你有一个指向nil
的指针,它是不可寻址的。然而,指向nil
的指针的指针(或指向接口的指针)是可寻址的。
你可以通过不同的方式使你的示例工作起来:
- 将
x
初始化为非nil
值(可能不是重点) - 使用
reflect.New(..)
将y
设置为新的Value
func main() {
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y)
fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{}))
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
y = reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()).Interface()
fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y)
}
英文:
In your example rv.CanAddr()
is false
and consequently you cannot set it (rv.CanSet()
is false
).
Problem: if you have a pointer to nil it is not addressable. A pointer to a pointer to nil (or a pointer to an interface) however is addressable.
You can get your example to work in different ways:
-
initialize x to be non-nil (probably not the point here)
-
set y to a new Value with
reflect.New(..)
func main() { var x *Foo var y interface{} = x fmt.Printf("Before: %#v\n", y) fmt.Printf("Goal: %#v\n", interface{}(&Foo{})) rv := reflect.ValueOf(y) y = reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()).Interface() fmt.Printf("After: %#v\n", y) }
答案3
得分: 1
根据你的示例,不知道你的实际用例,很难确定你需要什么解决方案,但是这个链接提供了一个解决方案:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
y = reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()).Interface()
英文:
Without knowing your actual use case, it's hard to say what solution you require, however this works for your example:
var x *Foo
var y interface{} = x
rv := reflect.ValueOf(y)
y = reflect.New(rv.Type().Elem()).Interface()
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。
评论