英文:
Fail to verify RSASSA-PSS signature across Python -> Go
问题
我已经将这个问题简化为最简单的测试案例。我需要在Go中验证使用Python生成的RSASSA-PSS签名。以下是用Python创建RSA密钥对并进行签名的代码:
>>> from tuf import pycrypto_keys as k
>>> pub, priv = k.generate_rsa_public_and_private()
>>> sig, method = k.create_rsa_signature(priv, "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog.")
>>> sig.encode("hex")
'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'
可以在这里找到所引用的pycrypto_keys库,以了解generate_rsa_public_and_private
和create_rsa_signature
函数的具体实现。
我的Go测试包含两个只依赖核心包的简单文件。首先是验证函数verify.go
:
package example
import (
"crypto"
"crypto/rsa"
"crypto/sha256"
"crypto/x509"
"fmt"
)
func Verify(key []byte, sig []byte, msg []byte) error {
digest := sha256.Sum256(msg)
pub, err := x509.ParsePKIXPublicKey(key)
if err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("Failed to parse key")
}
rsaPub, ok := pub.(*rsa.PublicKey)
if !ok {
return fmt.Errorf("Invalid value returned from ParsePKIXPublicKey")
}
opts := rsa.PSSOptions{SaltLength: 16, Hash: crypto.SHA256}
if err = rsa.VerifyPSS(rsaPub, crypto.SHA256, digest[:], sig, &opts); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("Failed Verification")
}
return nil
}
其次是一个测试案例。密钥对和签名是使用上面的Python命令生成的,并将其复制到这里以创建一组静态参数,用于兼容性测试。
package example
import (
"encoding/hex"
"encoding/pem"
"testing"
)
func TestPyCryptoRSACompatVerify(t *testing.T) {
pubPem := "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----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\n1ANMFPxDQpHudCLxwCzjCb+sVa20HBRPTnzo8LSZkI6jAgMBAAE=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----"
//privPem := "-----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY-----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\n/qNP5JetY0eH6C+KRc8JqDB0nvbqZNOgYXOfYXo/5Gk8XIHTFihm\n-----END RSA PRIVATE KEY-----"
testStr := "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog."
sigHex := "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"
testKey, _ := pem.Decode([]byte(pubPem))
sigBytes, err := hex.DecodeString(sigHex)
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
err = Verify(testKey.Bytes, sigBytes, []byte(testStr))
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
}
代码在Verify函数的最后一次检查中失败,输出错误信息Failed Verification
。我查看了Go的PSS验证代码,如果出现任何问题,都会返回一个通用的验证错误,因此并不是很有帮助。即使它更具体,要么存在兼容性问题,要么是语言实现中的错误,要么是我的代码有问题。
非常感谢您的帮助。
英文:
I've boiled this down to the simplest test case I can. I need to take RSASSA-PSS signatures that were generated in Python and validate them in Go. The Python code to create the RSA keypair and sign with it is as follows:
>>> from tuf import pycrypto_keys as k
>>> pub, priv = k.generate_rsa_public_and_private()
>>> sig, method = k.create_rsa_signature(priv, "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog.")
>>> sig.encode("hex")
'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'
The pycrypto_keys library referenced there can be found here for reference of the specific implementation of the functions generate_rsa_public_and_private
and create_rsa_signature
.
My Go test consists of 2 simple files that only rely on core packages. First the verification function, in verify.go:
package example
import (
"crypto"
"crypto/rsa"
"crypto/sha256"
"crypto/x509"
"fmt"
)
func Verify(key []byte, sig []byte, msg []byte) error {
digest := sha256.Sum256(msg)
pub, err := x509.ParsePKIXPublicKey(key)
if err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("Failed to parse key")
}
rsaPub, ok := pub.(*rsa.PublicKey)
if !ok {
return fmt.Errorf("Invalid value returned from ParsePKIXPublicKey")
}
opts := rsa.PSSOptions{SaltLength: 16, Hash: crypto.SHA256}
if err = rsa.VerifyPSS(rsaPub, crypto.SHA256, digest[:], sig, &opts); err != nil {
return fmt.Errorf("Failed Verification")
}
return nil
}
And second, a test case. The key pair and signature were generated using the Python commands at the top and copied in here to create a static set of parameters to use for compatibility testing.
package example
import (
"encoding/hex"
"encoding/pem"
"testing"
)
func TestPyCryptoRSACompatVerify(t *testing.T) {
pubPem := "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----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\n1ANMFPxDQpHudCLxwCzjCb+sVa20HBRPTnzo8LSZkI6jAgMBAAE=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----"
//privPem := "-----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY-----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\n/qNP5JetY0eH6C+KRc8JqDB0nvbqZNOgYXOfYXo/5Gk8XIHTFihm\n-----END RSA PRIVATE KEY-----"
testStr := "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog."
sigHex := "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"
testKey, _ := pem.Decode([]byte(pubPem))
sigBytes, err := hex.DecodeString(sigHex)
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
err = Verify(testKey.Bytes, sigBytes, []byte(testStr))
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
}
The code fails in the final check of the Verify function, outputting the error Failed verification
. I've had a look at the Go PSS verification code and if anything goes wrong, a generic verification error is returned so it's not that helpful. Even if it was more specific, either there is a compatibility problem here, a bug in one of the language implementations, or my code is wrong.
Much thanks for any help.
答案1
得分: 0
所以看起来我在Python代码中误解了_SALT_SIZE
。在TUF开发人员的帮助下(也就是他们告诉我),我发现__PyCrypto的RSA PSS代码推断盐的大小等于正在使用的哈希算法的哈希摘要的大小__。在这种情况下,哈希算法是Sha256,所以盐的大小是32字节。只需更改opts := rsa.PSSOptions{SaltLength: 32, Hash: crypto.SHA256}
,代码就可以正常工作。
英文:
So it appears I misinterpreted _SALT_SIZE
in the Python code. With some help from the TUF developers (i.e. they told me) I discovered PyCrypto's RSA PSS code infers the salt size to be equal to the size of the hash digest of the hashing algorithm in use. In this case it was 32 bytes as the hashing algorithm was Sha256. With just the change of opts := rsa.PSSOptions{SaltLength: 32, Hash: crypto.SHA256}
the code works.
通过集体智慧和协作来改善编程学习和解决问题的方式。致力于成为全球开发者共同参与的知识库,让每个人都能够通过互相帮助和分享经验来进步。
评论